Old Chatham Creamery – Premium Sheep Milk Yogurt & Artisan Cowgirl Creamery Mt Tam Cheese
Old Chatham Creamery crafts luxurious sheep milk yogurt and partners with Cowgirl Creamery for their award-winning Organic Mt Tam triple-cream cheese. The rich, creamy sheep milk yogurt is available in plain 24 oz and 6 oz sizes, while the velvety Mt Tam offers a decadent, buttery flavor in 7 oz wheels. Perfect for breakfast, snacking, charcuterie boards, or gourmet cooking – pure, high-quality dairy from small-batch production at oldchathamcreamery.org.
Old Chatham Creamery Usage
Rich & Creamy Breakfast
Plain sheep milk yogurt provides a thick, velvety texture and mild tangy flavor – delicious with fresh fruit, granola, or honey for a nourishing start to the day.
Healthy Snacking & Smoothies
High-protein sheep milk yogurt is excellent on its own or blended into smoothies for a creamy, nutrient-dense snack any time of day.
Gourmet Cheese Board Star
Organic Mt Tam triple-cream cheese brings a soft, buttery, and slightly sweet profile that pairs beautifully with crackers, fruits, nuts, and wines.
Versatile Cooking Ingredient
Use sheep milk yogurt in marinades, sauces, baking, or as a sour cream substitute for a richer, more elegant flavor.
Convenient Size Options
Larger 24 oz tubs for families and smaller 6 oz cups for individual portions or on-the-go snacking.
Artisan Quality Dairy
Small-batch production using premium sheep milk and organic ingredients ensures exceptional taste and quality in every product.
Old Chatham Creamery Bestsellers
Co Plain Sheep Milk Yogurt, 24 Oz
Old Chatham Creamery Plain Sheep Milk Yogurt – 24 oz tub. Rich, creamy, and mildly tangy with a luxurious texture. Ideal for breakfast, smoothies, or as a versatile cooking ingredient.
Company Sheep'S Milk Yogurt, Plain, 6 oz
Old Chatham Creamery Plain Sheep Milk Yogurt – 6 oz single serve cup. Convenient size with the same high-quality, creamy texture and delicate flavor. Perfect for on-the-go snacking or portion control.
Cowgirl Creamery — Organic Mt Tam, 7 Oz
Cowgirl Creamery Organic Mt Tam triple-cream cheese – 7 oz wheel. Soft, buttery, and elegantly flavored artisan cheese. Excellent for cheese boards, appetizers, or gourmet snacking.
Why Customers Choose Old Chatham Creamery
Old Chatham Creamery values and considers the needs of its customers and hopes to please everyone.
Superior Sheep Milk Yogurt
Naturally richer and creamier than cow milk yogurt with higher protein and a luxurious mouthfeel.
Award-Winning Mt Tam Cheese
Cowgirl Creamery’s iconic triple-cream cheese offers a refined, buttery flavor loved by cheese enthusiasts.
Pure & Natural Ingredients
Made with minimal processing and high-quality milk – no artificial additives for clean, authentic dairy taste.
Old Chatham Creamery Company Values
Old Chatham Creamery focuses on small-batch craftsmanship, exceptional creaminess, pure ingredients, rich flavor, and versatility – delivering premium sheep milk yogurt and artisan cheese that elevate everyday meals and special occasions.
- Sheep Milk Yogurt: Naturally creamy
- Organic Mt Tam: Triple-cream delight
- Plain Flavor: Versatile base
- Small-Batch: Artisan quality
- Multiple Sizes: Family & single
- Rich Texture: Luxurious mouthfeel
Photos by Our Happy Clients
Old Chatham Creamery Reviews
Our satisfied customers have found Old Chatham Creamery solutions to be remarkably effective and user-friendly, as evidenced by the following reviews
Do you need a Old Chatham Creamery
Contact our knowledgeable team at for a consultation, where we’will provide customized guidance and recommendations tailored to your needs.